Earlier this morning, members of Colorado’s Congressional delegation asked the leaders of Arizonans for Responsible Drug Policy (ARDP), which opposes legalization in Arizona, to stop airing ads that contain false claims about Colorado’s legalization experience.
Sen. Pat Steadman, Rep. Millie Hamner, and Rep. Jonathan Singer sent a letter via email to ARDP leaders Seth Leibsohn and Sheila Polk (pictured above with microphone). The Congress members cite multiple incorrect statements regarding cannabis revenue spending and teen usage rates in Colorado. The letter includes documents from Colorado government agencies that directly contradict the false claims made in the video.
“As member of the Colorado Legislature who played a central role in budgeting and appropriation of marijuana tax revenues,” the email from the legislators read. “We feel it is our duty to set the record straight so that voters in both [Arizona and Colorado] have accurate information about the subject.”
One ad, entitled “Mistake,” features former Colorado Governor Bill Owens, who led the state from 1999 through 2007, and former Denver Mayor Wellington Webb (in office from 1991 to 2003). Owens and Webb claim that cannabis tax revenue was mostly going to cover regulation of the cannabis industry. Another ad, “Empty Promises,” interviews two public school officials who claim that the promise of revenue for schools were “empty words.”
Both ads claim that marijuana tax revenue never made it to Colorado schools and that most of the revenue was spent on regulation. In fact, more than $138 million was distributed to the Colorado Department of Education, while just $21.5 million (or about 10 percent) of total excise tax revenue was spent on regulation. Indeed, nearly $115 million was allotted for the Building Excellent Schools Today (BEST) public school construction program, as well as more than $5.5 million to increase the presence of health professionals in public schools.
Another false claim rang hollow when faced with further scrutiny. The ads say that “marijuana use among our students soared.” However, according to the Healthy Kids Colorado Survey in 2015, cannabis use among youth remains relatively unchanged since 2009 and were actually lower in 2015 than the usage rates prior to legalization.
“We respectfully request that you stop airing or otherwise publishing ads that contradict these facts,” the letter asks. “We also trust that they will be reflected in any of your future communications to Arizona voters regarding Colorado’s experience with regulating and taxing marijuana for adult use.”
The letter is signed by Rep. Jonathan Singer, a member of the Colorado House Appropriations Committee, Rep. Millie Hamner, Chair of the Colorado Joint Budget Committee and Vice Chair for the Colorado House Appropriations Committee and Sen. Pat Steadman, member of both the Colorado Joint Budget Committee of the Colorado Senate Appropriations Committee.
The full letter is as follows:
Dear Mr. Leibsohn and Ms. Polk:
It has been brought to our attention that your committee has produced and aired television ads that convey inaccurate and misleading statements about Colorado’s experience with regulating and taxing marijuana for adult use.
Specifically, your ad titled “Empty Promises” features a former Colorado local school official saying, “We were promised millions of new revenues for our schools, but they were empty words.” It also features a Colorado school principal saying, “Politicians spent more money on regulation and bureaucracy than in the classroom.” Similarly, in your ad titled “Mistake,” former Denver mayor Wellington Webb says, “We were promised new money for education. Instead, that money is going to regulation and the pot industry.”
The proponents of the initiative you are opposing and members of the Arizona media have raised questions about the validity of these claims. We have also heard from Colorado residents who read or saw stories about these ads in our local media outlets and were confused by the claims that they make.
As members of the Colorado Legislature who played intimate roles in the budgeting and appropriation of marijuana tax revenues, we feel it is our duty to set the record straight so that voters in both states have accurate information about this subject.
We can say with certainty that the claims about Colorado marijuana tax revenues featured in your committee’s ads range from highly misleading to wholly inaccurate. As you can see in the attached issue brief provided by Colorado Legislative Council staff and fact sheet produced by the Colorado Department of Education:
Of the approximately $220.8 million in total marijuana tax revenue distributions made in FY 2015-16 and FY 2016-17, more than $138.3 million was distributed to the Colorado Department of Education to benefit Colorado schools. This far exceeds the amount that was distributed for the purposes of regulating marijuana, which included $15.8 to the Department of Revenue, $2.4 million to the Department of Agriculture, $2.8 million to the Department of Law, and less than $500,000 to the Governor’s Office of Marijuana Coordination.
Of those funds, $114.9 million was distributed to the Building Excellent Schools Today (BEST) public school construction program. When Colorado voters adopted Amendment 64, they were promised a tax on wholesale marijuana transfers would raise $40 million per year for the BEST program. That tax actually raised more than $40 million in the last fiscal year, resulting in $40 million for the BEST program in FY 2016-17, plus an additional $5.7 million for Colorado’s Public School Fund.
In addition to the funds raised for the BEST program and the Public School Fund, more than $5.5 million was used to increase the presence of health professionals in our schools, and more than $4.3 million was used for health-related programs in schools. In addition, $2.9 million was used for drop-out prevention programs, and $2.9 million was used for school bullying prevention and education.
It is also worth noting that more than $1.5 million in marijuana tax funds were distributed to the Department of Public Health and Environment to conduct the Healthy Kids Colorado Survey, which is the most comprehensive survey of our state’s middle and high school students. As you can see in the attached fact sheet from that department, the survey’s findings contradict the claim that “marijuana use among our students soared,” which is made in your ad titled “Empty Promises.” Rates of teen use have actually remained relatively unchanged since 2009 and are in line with the national average. In fact, they were slightly lower last year than they were prior to legalization.
We respectfully request that you stop airing or otherwise publishing campaign ads that contradict these facts. We also trust they will be reflected in any of your future communications to Arizona voters regarding Colorado’s experience with regulating and taxing marijuana for adult use.
Rep. Jonathan Singer
Member, Colorado House Appropriations Committee
Rep. Millie Hamner
Chair, Colorado Joint Budget Committee
Vice Chair, Colorado House Appropriations Committee
Sen. Pat Steadman
Member, Colorado Joint Budget Committee
Member, Colorado Senate Appropriations Committee
Lead Image: Gage Skidmore/Flickr Creative Commons